Who Made This?
Who Made This?
In the world of medicine, you will often have the choice between brand name drugs or generic equivalents. Developing new (pharmaceutical drugs) is big business. To protect the company’s investment in R&D, the drug company has a window during which their patented drug may not be copied. The drug company has a short-lived monopoly, and generally prices the drug the way you would expect a monopolist to price, i.e, they charge like a wounded bull. Once the patent expires, other companies may market their versions of the drug and all those lovely free market forces come into play, so generic drugs are usually vastly cheaper than the brand name drug.
With drugs, unless you are an analytical chemist, it’s difficult to know exactly what you are buying. (Although if you want to test for fake little blue pills, it’s not hard.) Judging by the enormous numbers of spam emails which I receive for gentlemen’s strengthening tablets, there is an enormous market out there for fake pharmaceuticals. And where a generic drug contains the same active ingredient as the brand name equivalent, a fake drug is exactly that: a sugar coated piece of chalk.
There’s a strong incentive to make fake drugs: the margins are enormous. I don’t know what the chalk costs, but having researched this stuff, for purely academic reasons, I suspect I am in the wrong business entirely. The little blue pills sell for around $4 each. That’s good margin for chalk!
In the world of car parts, it’s a similar story, with hopefully a lot less spam involved. The pecking order for car parts goes mostly like this:
Genuine Parts
OEM Parts
Aftermarket Parts
Fake Parts
Genuine parts carry the marque’s branding. For some parts, there is no option. If you want a steering column switch for your Porsche Boxster or 996, it’s a genuine Porsche part.
OEM parts are the same parts as fitted in the factory, but with the manufacturer’s branding. If you buy a genuine MINI oil filter, you get a Mahle filter in a MINI box. If you buy genuine Porsche brake pads, you get either Pagid or Textar pads in a Porsche box. What you don’t get with OEM parts is the ‘genuine’ price. This is why Master Parts sells OEM parts as far as possible.
Aftermarket parts covers a broad range, from high quality items manufactured by reputable brands, to parts that are just plain junk. If a Mahle oil filter for a particular car is not the factory fitment, then that filter is not OEM, but it can get murky. F’rinstance if Porsche use a Mahle oil filter for one model, and a Mann cabin air filter, then Mahle are OEM for oil filters, but aftermarket for cabin filters for that model. Some aftermarket parts are indistinguishable from OEM (and genuine) parts, and in some cases it doesn’t really matter. Cabin air filters are probably a good example. There’s probably very little down side risk to using an aftermarket cabin air filter, but you’d be brave if you made it your mission in life to seek out the cheapest oil filter for your car.
The tricky thing with the term ‘aftermarket’ parts is that it covers everything from totally unserviceable items that bear a passing resemblance to useful car parts to items that are substantial improvements over the factory fitted items. Within the Master Parts range, examples of aftermarket parts that are upgrades from factory fit items are:
Numeric Racing shifters and cables for 996/7 and 986/7 models
BMP aluminium coolant reservoirs for R53 MINI Cooper S
L and N Engineering IMS bearing updates for 996 and 986 model Porsches
And then there are fake parts. Piracy in car parts really does exist. I’ve been shown examples of fake oil filters, air filters, clutch components and brake pads. It goes without saying that buying fake parts is just not worth it. Of course, nobody would knowingly buy fake parts but the old wisdom holds true: if a deal looks too good to be true, it probably is.
So, the question arises: If you have a choice, which car parts should you buy? The answer is simple: First prize is OEM, where this is available. You get genuine part quality without genuine part prices. If OEM is not available, look for OEM equivalent aftermarket parts. Within the parts you’ll find on materparts.com.au we’ve made every effort to indicate the part’s manufacturer, and if you are interested in a part that doesn’t have a manufacturer identified, please ask.
In the world of medicine, you will often have the choice between brand name drugs or generic equivalents. Developing new (pharmaceutical drugs) is big business. To protect the company’s investment in R&D, the drug company has a window during which their patented drug may not be copied. The drug company has a short-lived monopoly, and generally prices the drug the way you would expect a monopolist to price, i.e, they charge like a wounded bull. Once the patent expires, other companies may market their versions of the drug and all those lovely free market forces come into play, so generic drugs are usually vastly cheaper than the brand name drug.
With drugs, unless you are an analytical chemist, it’s difficult to know exactly what you are buying. (Although if you want to test for fake little blue pills, it’s not hard.) Judging by the enormous numbers of spam emails which I receive for gentlemen’s strengthening tablets, there is an enormous market out there for fake pharmaceuticals. And where a generic drug contains the same active ingredient as the brand name equivalent, a fake drug is exactly that: a sugar coated piece of chalk.
There’s a strong incentive to make fake drugs: the margins are enormous. I don’t know what the chalk costs, but having researched this stuff, for purely academic reasons, I suspect I am in the wrong business entirely. The little blue pills sell for around $4 each. That’s good margin for chalk!
In the world of car parts, it’s a similar story, with hopefully a lot less spam involved. The pecking order for car parts goes mostly like this:
Genuine Parts
OEM Parts
Aftermarket Parts
Fake Parts
Genuine parts carry the marque’s branding. For some parts, there is no option. If you want a steering column switch for your Porsche Boxster or 996, it’s a genuine Porsche part.
OEM parts are the same parts as fitted in the factory, but with the manufacturer’s branding. If you buy a genuine MINI oil filter, you get a Mahle filter in a MINI box. If you buy genuine Porsche brake pads, you get either Pagid or Textar pads in a Porsche box. What you don’t get with OEM parts is the ‘genuine’ price. This is why Master Parts sells OEM parts as far as possible.
Aftermarket parts covers a broad range, from high quality items manufactured by reputable brands, to parts that are just plain junk. If a Mahle oil filter for a particular car is not the factory fitment, then that filter is not OEM, but it can get murky. F’rinstance if Porsche use a Mahle oil filter for one model, and a Mann cabin air filter, then Mahle are OEM for oil filters, but aftermarket for cabin filters for that model. Some aftermarket parts are indistinguishable from OEM (and genuine) parts, and in some cases it doesn’t really matter. Cabin air filters are probably a good example. There’s probably very little down side risk to using an aftermarket cabin air filter, but you’d be brave if you made it your mission in life to seek out the cheapest oil filter for your car.
The tricky thing with the term ‘aftermarket’ parts is that it covers everything from totally unserviceable items that bear a passing resemblance to useful car parts to items that are substantial improvements over the factory fitted items. Within the Master Parts range, examples of aftermarket parts that are upgrades from factory fit items are:
Numeric Racing shifters and cables for 996/7 and 986/7 models
BMP aluminium coolant reservoirs for R53 MINI Cooper S
L and N Engineering IMS bearing updates for 996 and 986 model Porsches
And then there are fake parts. Piracy in car parts really does exist. I’ve been shown examples of fake oil filters, air filters, clutch components and brake pads. It goes without saying that buying fake parts is just not worth it. Of course, nobody would knowingly buy fake parts but the old wisdom holds true: if a deal looks too good to be true, it probably is.
So, the question arises: If you have a choice, which car parts should you buy? The answer is simple: First prize is OEM, where this is available. You get genuine part quality without genuine part prices. If OEM is not available, look for OEM equivalent aftermarket parts. Within the parts you’ll find on materparts.com.au we’ve made every effort to indicate the part’s manufacturer, and if you are interested in a part that doesn’t have a manufacturer identified, please ask.
Comment(s)0